
Jon Krakauer’s, Where Men Win Glory
For each book, I will do a quasi-review using the following Sergio Leone-inspired layout:
The Good: For starters, and I will lead with this every time, Scott Brick was phenomenal. He could read the alphabet, and it would hold my attention. I can’t speak for other audio book readers, but for me, the narrator makes such an enormous difference. With novels, Dick Hill and George Guidall are legends, and rightly so, several of the novelists that are must-reads for me, are so because of those 2 guys. Scott Brick is quickly becoming one of those narrators for me. It is just incredible. I have a personal rule: for non-fiction texts, the author had better be the narrator. How can you properly communicate the message of your book, if you’re not doing the reading? Well, now there’s an amendment: if you’re not going to read it yourself, use Scott Brick. He was fantastic.
Having said that, even if you’re not an audio book reader, I think nearly all Americans should read this book. If nothing else, Krakauer does yeoman’s work of explaining the history of Afghanistan, Osama bin Laden, and all of the events that have led to that theatre’s inclusion in the Global War on Terror. It is very necessary.
The Bad: Of course, Krakauer is a pinko loon, granola Leftist partisan, without a doubt. I don’t care about that, for the reasons stated above. But, he really just doesn’t get it when it comes to Pat Tillman’s significance. I have, through my graduate studies, encountered a surprising number of American men aged 18-28 who have been to Afghanistan or Iraq, who have contributed to the insurance of our lifestyle and Western civilization. They truly are the new “Greatest Generation”, just heroes, all. However, outside of my academic universe, there is very little interaction or sacrifice being made by me or my peers in this global conflict. We are at war. And so little of the American public has been impacted by that. This is atypical of the American experience of our wars, and that is not a good thing. Pat Tillman really, really understood that. And that is the importance of Tillman’s story. So many of our heroes of past generations; athletic, pop cultural, political, they all were also war heroes. They gave back to the nation that gave them so much opportunity, and they pitched in, unflinchingly, when she was threatened. The fact that Tillman has become the anomaly in that capacity is a sad, sad statement as to where we our as a nation. Pat Tillman should be the standard for our heroes, and that should be the message.
The Ugly: There isn’t much. But Krakauer does suffer incessantly from Bush Derangement Syndrome. He spends vast expanses of words and pages railing needlessly, and vitriolic, against the Bush Administration. It seems strangely out of place, and does a disservice to the seriously good story telling that he presents. It’s just sad, really.
Overall Review: 3.5 out of 5. It is a must read, simply because it is like a Cliff Notes for the Global War on Terror. If you can look past the Bush-bashing.